Dan56 ( talk) 09:04, 11 September 2018 (UTC) "You have no ground for reverting my replacement of Slant Magazine's score with AllMusic" - clearly stated in my edit summary: "ESSAY notes " keeping a neutral point of view", which is POLICY. If you revert it again, even after I have given this thorough explanation of a relatively minor change, I will open an RfC. In sum, my revision meets the relevant guidelines ( MOS:ALBUM#Album ratings template, WP:NPOV). If Slant's score were included in the arithmetic, the average would bump up higher to 76.6, which is higher than either aggregate score. If you include AllMusic's score and assign each of the 10 listed a value out of 100, and average them out, you get: 50 + 67 + 83 + 80 + 80 + 80 + 80 + 65 + 70 + 91 = 746, divided by 10, for an average of 74.6, which is roughly the average of the two aggregate scores, 74 and 76. If we are to consider the averaged scores from either of the listed aggregate sites-AnyDecentMusic (a 74) or Metacritic (a 76, out of 100)-then the average with AllMusic's score in place of Slant's is no less an accurate reflection than with Slant.Considering notability of the review source, AllMusic warrants inclusion over Slant. In fact, Slant appears to be the least popular publication among those listed in the ratings box. Both are American publications, but AllMusic is the more popular publication by a wide margin, according to Alexa's traffic rank: AllMusic is ranked 1,424 in the U.S.The ratings template guideline states: "When choosing which reviews to include, consider the notability of the review source and keeping a neutral point of view.".Nothing was said or suggested by me or my change, in regards to any of these confusing statements you made in your edit summary. I have no idea what you're on about here: ("ESSAY notes "keeping a neutral point of view"), ("All listed are notable"), ("worldwide overview over American focus"), ("no policy says AllMusic (or any one particular site) must be listed"). If you found an error with any archives or the URLs themselves, you can fix them with this tool.Ĭheers.- InternetArchiveBot ( Report bug) 21:51, 2 November 2017 (UTC) Replacing Slant with AllMusic Lapadite77:, you have no ground for reverting my replacement of Slant Magazine's score with AllMusic.If you have discovered URLs which were erroneously considered dead by the bot, you can report them with this tool."Les Confidences d'Alicia Keys, Princesse R'N'B". "Emeli Sande and Alicia Keys Heading Back to The Studio". "Alicia Keys on New Album: "It's More About What We're Going Through as Human Beings" ". "Pharrell Talks New Alicia Keys Album: 'It Supersedes Anything That's Out' ". "Alicia Keys Asks the Big Questions on New Song, 'We Are Here': Listen". ^ "BBC Radio Manchester - The People, Laura White"."Rising Star Gabi Wilson Talks 'A Classic Holiday' LP, Alicia Keys, Celebrating the Holidays, Her Debut Album, More".
"Alicia Keys' New Album Slated For Early 2015". "Alicia Keys on Her Upcoming Album: 'It's the Best Music I've Ever Done In My Life' ". "Alicia Keys New Album Planned for Early 2015: 'No One' Singer Working on Conceptual Effort". ^ "Pharrell and Alicia Keys Talk 'The Voice,' and Her New Album"."Alicia Keys Fronts Givenchy's Newest Fragrance".
0 kommentar(er)
